All Clear on EU/Migrant Resettlement?
"We need to take back control of our borders.""What we are pushing for is a more sustainable and, I will also say, a more orderly asylum and migration system.""As everybody knows, criminal organizations are making billions of euros on human smuggling, and too many lives are lost at sea.""We will break down the business model of human smugglers. We will take back control of our borders.""[Some European leaders have been working toward this kind of initiative for] eight or nine years."Danish Prime Minister Mette Frederiksen"The question is: What kind of due diligence has been done by these five countries?""It's very concerning that the risk of human rights harms are being kind of swept under the carpet in order to present an image of coming up with solutions.""[The plan is] utterly deplorable."Clémentine de Montjoye, Nairobi, Kenya, senior researcher, Africa division, Human Rights Watch"[There is a need to manage migration in a more orderly way; the Rwanda deal will act only as a] fig leaf [rather than a real deterrent]""[Smugglers will adapt, and asylum seekers who feel they have no alternative will continue to make risky journeys, even if the odds of being allowed to stay are lower].""This is more about politics than migration policy. Governments, actually across the political spectrum, have made a tough border as part of their promises to voters."Roberto Forin, deputy director, Mixed Migration Centre
![]() |
| From left: Dutch Foreign Minister Tom Berendsen, German Interior Minister Alexander Dobrindt, Austrian Interior Minister Gerhard Karner, Denmark's Prime Minister Mette Frederiksen, Austrian Chancellor Christian Stocker, Rwandan Interior Minister Vincent Biruta, Greek Minister for Migration and Asylum Athanasios Plevris and Danish Minister of Immigration and Integration Morten Bodskov pose for a family photo in Vienna on Monday. (Leonhard Foeger/Reuters) |
In the UK, under then-Prime Minister Boris Johnson, the idea was floated in 2022 that asylum seekers arriving in Britain would be sent to Rwanda; legal obstacles got in the way of enacting that program. Now, however, five EU countries plan to establish a migrant deportation centre located in Rwanda. Together, Austria, Denmark, Germany, Greece and the Netherlands have initiated a 'solution' to the unsustainable invasion of migrants to Europe, for the most part from Africa and the Middle East.
The plan appears fairly moderate for the time being in numbers under discussion; some 100 migrants, men and women, but not minors -- whose applications for asylum have been rejected, despite which the applicants refuse invitations to return to their home countries after having exhausted all options available to them legally to appeal the decisions, in the five European countries that form the ejection pact.
Irrespective of where the migrants have emanated from -- Ukraine, Afghanistan, Syria, Latin America -- all are eligible for consideration to become part of the 'return-hub'. The concern among NGOs is that ultimately the initiative will target failed asylum seekers, denied by the countries involved in the plan. National authorities of the five European countries will be responsible for the transfer to Rwanda of their ejected asylum seekers.
![]() |
| Migrants board a coast guard boat from a Frontex vessel, to be transferred to the port of Kaloi Limenes, following a rescue operation on the island of Crete, Greece, on Nov. 9. (Stefanos Rapanis/Reuters) |
On arrival in Rwanda, the authorities of the east African country will undertake charge of the transferred individuals' well-being. Residence permits will be distributed, and each individual will be assigned to a "welcome centre", which the European countries involved in the transfer assure their critics will be open, liberties will not be constrained, and the centre will not be confused with a barbed-wire holding camp.
The migrants are meant to be resident in the centre for several months, the intention being that they will gradually be integrated into Rwandan society. Vocational training and language courses will be offered. The European countries in this arrangement state their intention to form an independent monitoring mechanism to ensure that respect for human rights is an integral part of the adjustment process. The option for the migrants to choose to return to their country of origin will remain open to them.
The hope is that out of this controversial arrangement, far from the expectations of the migrants when they entered Europe, is that this new reality will be sufficiently convincing to any other would-be migrants that entry to the European continent has become much more problematical and once entered, their prospects to remain will have become much more difficult.
As far as the five European countries are concerned now, the legal basis on which this arrangement has been made is solid, having altered EU legislation on returns a few months earlier. What Rwanda might have been promised in return for their compliance is not a subject under discussion. Concerns that have been raised over migrant treatment have been dismissed, although the expectation is that there will be court challenges to their plan.
![]() |
| A bicycle taxi driver looks on while waiting for customers at a busy junction near a market in Kigali, on July 16, 2024. The east African nation is set to host a deportation hub for failed asylum seekers from five European countries. (Luis Tato/AFP/Getty Images) |
Labels: Austria/Denmark/Germany/Greece/Netherlands Plan, Migrant Deportations, Migrants to Europe, Rejected Applicants, Rwanda Receiving Centre




0 Comments:
Post a Comment
<< Home