Canada Experiencing Reverse Brain-Drain Resources

"There is a lot of concern and incredulity that this is happening."

"The kinds of people that might be available are fairly high flyers. This is a big deal. It's not like minor frustration over prior presidents, or differences of opinion with policy. I think people would be in play if you could make jobs available."

"I think we will definitely get some people."
"There's a disturbance in the force, so to speak. Americans are considering relocation options and career moves they haven't considered before."

"For Canada to cash in on this angst, we'd have to deal with the fact that we currently don't have lots of empty jobs in academic medicine. We'd also have to come up with the startup funds newly hired faculty need to build their research labs." 

"Advertising and promoting that idea recruiting practising doctors by ensuring American physicians are considered on par with Canadian doctors] of, 'We welcome you in Canada, and we'll make sure that we expedite your licensure and help with moving  you to Canada', could free up lots of very talented physicians who are not researchers but who would help our healthcare system."

Dr. Stephen Archer, director, Translational Institute of Medicine, Queen's University, Kingston, Ontario

 

"Compared to 2018, in 2024 there is close to a 300 percent increase in the number of [certifications] awarded via this route (198 in 2018 versus 775+ in 2024)."

"The CFFC [College of Family physicians of Canada] welcomes American family doctors, as we always have."

"Every additional family physician certified by the CFPC means another doctor caring for more Canadians."

College of Family Physicians of Canada president Dr. Carrie Bernard 

Robert F. Kennedy Jr, a vaccine critic who has pledged to tackle chronic disease, was named U.S. Health Secretary on Thursday after overcoming resistance from the medical establishment and members of Congress with promises to limit his role in vaccination policy.  CBC

 

There has been an unprecedented surge in interest from American doctors looking to re-locate from the United States where President Donald Trump has gone on a spree of re-ordering and cost-cutting in science and medicine affecting the quality of research and medical services in the United States. Suddenly Canada has become an attractive alternative for a growing number of family physicians and medical researchers. For Canada, that surging interest couldn't come at a better time, given the country's shortage of general practitioners and a medical system that is collapsing under the weight of demands it cannot meet.

 

The founder of CanAm Physician Recruiting Inc., a firm in business for the last 27 years, states that its current job board lists over 150 open positions across Canada. A typical listing would be: 'Family physician in Edmonton -- Guaranteed salary and No Overheads in Fantastic Location'. And others reading: Anesthesiologist in Calgary, obstetrician/gynecologist in Moncton, emergency doctors in 'multiple locations'. 

 

For years, the Centers for Disease Control has been at the front lines of disease outbreak response in the U.S. and abroad, including meningitis, Ebola and more. (Pouya Dianat/The Associated Press)

 

Evidently it appears that a number of American doctors and academics contemplate leaving the United States in response to what many of the country's elite scientists and medical researchers call the "wholesale assault" on science by the Trump administration. This represents a historical turn-about, where Canada typically educates doctors who then see fit to relocate to the United States. In the current situation, Canada has become one of the preferred destinations of American doctors looking elsewhere to raise their families and operate their medical practises.

 

Canada should be prepared to welcome these professional health workers with open arms given the Canadian health-care system's desperate need of more physicians. Some observers recommend the creation of a special university hiring track for 'high flyers', along with an increase in grant funding agencies through boosting research and development spending by government alongside a robust strategic recruitment campaign.

 

Hundreds of millions in university grants and contracts has been slashed or paused, since the Trump administration took office, with 20,000 positions eliminated from American health agencies, defunding of laboratories, and cuts to some areas of research related to sex, gender and reproduction, under sweeping changes that Health Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. and Tesla chief executive Elon Musk have led. 

 

Department of Health and Human Services employee Julie Siegel stands outside the Mary E. Switzer Memorial Building in Washington, D.C., on Tuesday, as she was denied access and her badge was taken away. (Kevin Lamarque/Reuters)

 

Canada, unfortunately, cannot hope to match the expenditure of the United States on science and health care. The budget of the Canadian Institutes of Health Research was $1.2 billion in 2020-21, a trifling amount in comparison to the expenditure of the U.S. National Institutes of Health's $45 billion during that same time frame, even taking into account that the population of the U.S. is almost ten times that of Canada's. 

It does  help the process of transitioning medical personnel from the United States to Canada when, over the past two years the College of Physicians and Surgeons of Ontario opened 'registration pathways' for doctors trained in the United States. The updates permit American board-certified physicians to practise without a need to complete additional qualifying professional 'upgrades' in training or exams. The college registered 351 American physicians following the changes in policy between 2023 and 2024.

 

The College of Family Physicians of Canada arranges automatic certification with no exams required for family doctors trained and certified in the United States. Three other approved jurisdictions', the United Kingdom, Ireland and Australia are offered the same automatic certification. Once they are certified they can obtain full licenses to practise in every Canadian province.

 

Dr. John Philpott, founder of CanAm Physician Recruiting Inc. reports having heard from American doctors working in family medicine, but also emergency medicine, general surgery, pediatrics, psychiatry, ob/gyn -- "all specialties, right across the board, from California, Arizona to Florida, New York to the Midwest". "I was talking to one of my staff, she was talking to an emerge doc yesterday. And the doctor said, 'Listen, I'm coming; I'm coming tomorrow. ASAP. Put me wherever'." 

Thousands of people at key health agencies in the United States have lost their jobs. Canadian provinces are hoping they continue their research north of the border. (Elijah Nouvelage/Getty Images)

"The nice thing about investing in science is it improves life. The payback to government through taxes and innovation are very quick."

"The accreditation of medical schools is done by the same agency, so there's a lot of similarity."

"And Canadian physicians, although this might be controversial, are reasonably well paid, relative to American physicians."

Dr. Stephen Archer

Global Trade Uncertainty

"[Businesses should] suspend [investments in the U.S. pending talks with the Trump administration, after a] brutal and unfounded 9decision in announcing its raft of tariffs against other countries]."

"Because what would be the message of having major European players investing billions of euros in the American economy at a time when they're hitting us?"

French President Emmanuel Macron

 

"If Trump really imposes high tariffs, Europe will have to respond, but the paradox is that the EU would be better off doing nothing."

"On the other hand, Trump seems to understand only the language of force, and this indicates the need for a strong and immediate response."

"Probably the hope, in Brussels, is that the response will be strong enough to induce Trump to negotiate and, soon, to backtrack."

Matteo Villa, senior analyst, Institute for International Political Studies, Italy

Atlantic Council

Dismay spread across the world of commerce and trade at U.S. President Donald Trump's sweeping new tariffs, shocking governments amidst threats of retaliation and calls for negotiations rescinding the new import taxes on goods globally. A tense world, anticipating that the American President would proceed with his threats of imposing stiff tariffs widely across the world, but hoping against hope he might set aside the clearly trade-antagonistic agenda he has been toying with, were shocked at the magnitude of the Wednesday tariff scheme.

 

Not all countries hard hit by the imposition of trade-crippling tariffs were eager to threaten retaliation; there were also calls for negotiations in hopes that -- the mercurial American president's sentiments on making other countries pay for what he counselled Americans was a 50-year rip-off of the American consuming public -- he would vacillate and withdraw his aggressive agenda in response to reasoned arguments.

 

The shock of universally applied import taxes that ranged from 10 to 54 percent which Mr. Trump characterized as 'getting back' at the steep tariffs other countries had imposed for decades on American products would result in factory jobs returning to the United States. "Taxpayers have been ripped off for more than 50 years. But it is not going to happen anymore", he said, with finality. "There are no winners in trade wars and tariff wars, and protectionism is not a way out ... It is clear to everyone that more and more countries are opposing the U.S.'s unilateral bullying actions", was the return message from Chinese Foreign Ministry spokesperson Guo Jiakun. 

 

A key exporter to the United States, of all manner of products from clothing to kitchenware, China announced a raft of retaliatory measures that would certainly raise prices for its merchandise to American consumers. France is prepared to see its wines and spirits, food industry, cosmetics, health, metals and aircraft impacted. Little can be gained, according to analysts, from an all-ut trade war, for any country, including the U.S. Higher tariffs have the potential to lower growth and raise inflation. 

Stock market turmoil deepened on Friday, as China hit back at tariffs announced by US President Donald Trump, raising the likelihood of an extended trade war and damage to the global economy.  Getty Images

It is the companies in the United States that buy goods to sell to Americans who pay the tariffs, aka taxes. And they are then left with the dilemma of whether they should absorb the additional costs, or to pass them on to consumers in higher prices. "He's not going to back off", warned Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick. "This is the reordering of global trade". Deals can be possible "only if these countries can change everything about themselves, which I doubt they will". 

As the European Union prepares its response, rumours of a tax imposed on American digital giants Google, Apple, Meta, Amazon and Microsoft advocated by France, have been in circulation. "Nobody wins in a trade war, that is not in our national interest." The U.K. government would react with "cool and calm heads", noted British Prime Minister Kier Starmer.

 

The U.S. had been adjusted to an average tariff of 25 to 30 percent, the "worst end of expectations", the highest since the early 20th Century, observed Deutsche Bank's Jim Reid, of the "radical policy reordering". Reflected by radically jolted financial markets, with oil prices sinking more than $2 a barrel, in response to the global trade uncertainty. 

Behind a television monitor showing U.S. President Donald Trump, the display board with the Dax curve shows falling share prices, in Frankfurt, Germany, on Thursday, after the tariff package announced by Trump has pushed share prices sharply into negative territory. (Arne Dedert/dpa/The Associated Press)

"This is a game chamber, not only for the U.S. economy but for the global economy."

"Many countries will likely end up in a recession."

Olu Sonola, Fitch Ratings' head, U.S. Economic Research

An Ancient, Epic Battle

"Within the context of Roman acts of war, there are no comparable finds of fighters."

"There are huge battlefields in Germany where weapons were found. But finding the dead, that is unique for the entire Roman history."

Michaela Binder, leader of archeological dig 

"They have various different battle wounds, which rules out execution. It is truly a battlefield."

"The most likely theory at the moment is that this is connected to the Danube campaigns of Emperor Domitian -- that's 86 to 96 AD."

"In the Roman Empire, there were strict burial rituals and precise rules had to be observed even for the time after death."

"Since cremations were common in the European parts of the Roman Empire at the time around 100 AD, body burials are an absolute exception. Finds of Roman skeletons from this period are therefore extremely rare."

Kristina Adler-Wolfl, head, Vienna City Archeological Department 

 

"In Vienna, you are always prepared to encounter Roman traces as soon as you open pavement or soil: after all, Vindobona [the ancient Roman-era name for what would later become Vienna] laid the foundation stone of our city."

"Thanks to numerous archaeological excavations in the area of today's Vienna, a great deal of knowledge is already available, and yet finds always lead to new and surprising findings."

Vienna’s Councillor for Culture and Science, Veronica Kaup-Hasler

People work on the excavation of a Roman mass grave from the end of the 1st century AD, in the Simmering district of Vienna, Austria, Nov. 7, 2024. A. Slonek/Novetus / AP

This archaeological find dating back to the 1st Century, will take its place alongside spectacular archaeological findings of ancient Troy, thanks to the 19th Century perseverance of German businessman-turned-archaeologist, Heinrich Schliemann who succeeded in uncovering the presence of Troy, Mycenae, and Tiryns in Turkey and Greece, against all odds when he was determined to prove that the poet Homer knew of what he wrote and those minutely-described sites existed. 

In Vienna, Austria, construction crews were busy renovating a soccer field in October of 2024, when they came upon an unexpected and quite unprecedented discovery through their excavations. There, before them, lay a pile of intertwined skeletal remains. They had uncovered a mass grave that dated to the 1st-century Roman Empire.

 

Following archaeological analysis, experts from the Vienna Museum offered a public presentation of the gravesite -- that they linked to "a catastrophic event in a military context", amidst evidence of the first known conflict that occurred in the region. 

Archaeological analysis of the remains determined the men were killed in battle

The site in the Vienna neighbourhood of Simmering, revealed the skeletal remains of 129 people. Excavation teams as well, found many dislocated bones. The total number of victims is over 150 individuals, representing a discovery of a type never before found in central Europe.

 

Typically, soldiers during the Roman Empire would be cremated. It was only during the 3rd century that this practise deviated. Each of the skeletons revealed under examination signs of injury. Leading the researchers to the conclusion that the bodies lying in the pit were deposited there hastily. 

All of the victims of deadly warfare found in the pit were male, mostly men aged between 20 to 30 years of age. Surveys indicated robust health prevailed by virtue of finding that signs of good dental health was prevalent among them.

Finding the buried bodies of early Roman soldiers is soldiers is extremely rare

Analysis by Carbon-14 was used to date the skeletal remains to between AD 80 and 130. Those dates, cross-checked against the known history of relics also discovered in the grave, consisting of armour, helmet cheek protectors, and studded nails that distinguished Roman military boots known as caligae.

The archaeological investigations revealed that injuries sustained by swords, spears, daggers and projectile bolts were identified as the causes of death. The expert team of investigators were led to the conclusion that that those who died had been part of an epic battle, an engaged military operation that ended in catastrophe for many.

Broader view of the site at the soccer field where the Roman burial was discovered. (Reiner Riedler/Wien Museum).

All for One -- and One For All

"We stand in grief with the families and loved ones of these extraordinary 'Dogface Soldiers' during this unimaginable time."

"But the search isn't finished until everyone is home. Words cannot express our gratitude to those still working around the clock during these extensive search and recovery efforts and  your unwavering commitment not to rest until all are found."

"This past week has been devastating. Though we have received some closure, the world is darker without them."

“This loss is simply devastating. We are wrapping our arms around the families and loved ones of our Soldiers [during this difficult time]."

Commander Maj.-Gen. Christopher Norrie, 3rd Infantry Division  

 

"It has been truly amazing and very humbling to watch the incredible recovery team from different commands, countries and continents come together and give everything to recover our Soldiers."

"Thank you, Lithuania, Poland, Estonia, the U.S. Navy and the Army Corps of Engineers."

"We are forever grateful."

 Lt. Gen. Charles Costanza, commanding general, V Corps

Military personnel work at the site of a rescue operation for missing US soldiers at Pabrade training ground, in Lithuania, on March 28.  Petras Malukas/AFP/Getty Images

 

"Lithuania mourns together with the American nation."

"Please accept my heartfelt condolences, as well as those of the Lithuanian people, to you, the loved ones of those who lost their lives, and all the people of the United States of America. "

"During this difficult time, our thoughts and prayers are with you."

Lithuanian President Gitanas Nausėda 

Under NATO, to give reassurance to Eastern Europe, member-countries of the military alliance were assigned to establish a Rapid Reaction Force as a deterrent and a defence against Russian designs on its neighbours. With a very real and demonstrated willingness to invade the borders of neighbouring nations, the Russian Federation's ambitions of territorial aggression and expansion gave birth to a renewed move by NATO to offer protection to its members under duress of potential invasion.

 

Among other member-nations the United States established a unit in Lithuania. On March 25, an American armoured vehicle with four U.S. soldiers aboard went astray in a marshy peat bog located at the huge General Silvestras Zukauskas training ground nearby the town of Pabrade. A search was undertaken and the location of the missing vehicle was found, though no vehicle was in sight. The almost-70-ton behemoth had sunk straight down, along with its personnel. 

 

The U.S. Army search for four soldiers who went missing during a scheduled training exercise near Pabradė, Lithuania.  U.S. Army

 

It took six days in a massive effort by American, Polish and Lithuanian armed forces to locate and dig the M88 Hercules vehicle out of the peat bog. The search was widened when three of the missing men of the 1st Armoured Brigade Combat Team, 3rd Infantry Division were found dead, and a fourth body of the missing soldiers evaded the search teams. On a tactical training exercise, the soldiers were reported, along with their vehicle to be missing early on Tuesday. 

The thick forests and swampy terrain around Pabrade, some ten kilometres west of the border with Belarus saw hundreds of Lithuanian and American soldiers and other rescuers searching, engaged in a rescue mission. On Wednesday the armoured vehicle's whereabouts was finally discovered, submerged in 4-1/2 metres of swamp water. 

Military helicopters, fixed-wing aircraft, unmanned aerial systems and search and rescue personnel were provided by the Lithuanian armed forces. Excavators, sluice and slurry pumps were brought to the site, along with other heavy construction equipment along with technical experts and several hundred tons of gravel and earth, all to help with the recovery mission.

 

American navy divers manoeuvred through thick layers of mud, clay and sediment "with zero visibility" to finally reach the 63-ton vehicle on Sunday evening. There they established several points where steel cables could be attached to enable the work involved in lifting the vehicle. During the effort of dragging the vehicle out of its submerged position, they began to lose traction, requiring more heavy dozers to provide additional grip. Two hours later the vehicle was pulled free of its ghastly grave.

 

Sgt. Edvin F. Franco, 25, of Glendale, California, Sgt. Jose Duenez, Jr., 25, of Joliet, Illinois and Pfc. Dante D. Taitano, 21, of Dededo, Guam.  U.S. Army

The navy dive team's work was not over. They then turned to searching the area with the use of radar for the presence of the still-missing fourth soldier. And his body was ultimately found, to join that of his other three comrades, to be returned to the United States and to their families, for burial. 

 

An undated photo of Staff Sgt. Troy S. Knutson-Collins, 28, of Battle Creek, Michigan, who died in a training mission in Lithuania.  U.S. Army

"I can’t say enough about the support our Lithuanian Allies have provided us. We have leaned on them, and they, alongside our Polish and Estonian Allies — and our own Sailors, Airmen and experts from the Corps of Engineers — have enabled us to find and bring home our Soldiers."

"This is a tragic event, but it reinforces what it means to have Allies and friends."

Gen. Christopher Donahue, commander of U.S. Army Europe and Africa

Charming Beijing Captivates Liberal Loyalty

"[These comments] deeply offended, [demonstrating a] terrible lapse in judgement [however, the episode could serve as a] teachable moment."

"This is a person of integrity who served his community as a senior police officer for ... more than a quarter of [a] century. He's made a terrible lapse in judgement."

"He's made his apology. He's made it to the public, he's made it to the individual concerned, he's made it directly to me, and he's going to continue with his candidacy."

"He has my confidence." 

Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney

 

"[The response by Mr. Carney is indeed a] teachable moment."

"It teaches us that Mark Carney will never stand up for Canada."

"If Mark Carney won't stand up for a Canadian against this foreign hostile regime now, how could we ever expect  him to stand up for Canada after the election?"

Conservative Party Leader Pierre Poilievre

 

"He is a police officer, and he ought to know that when the CCP [Chinese Communist Party] went out and put a bounty on anybody, including Canadians, that cannot be acceptable."

"That is intimidation at its worst."

NDP MP Jenny Kwan

 

"What we saw was the news of the bounty was sort of re-upped, but we're just watching the open space for anything related to that." 

"That alone, I think, is a form of coercion."

"Spreading, again, the information about the bounty is precisely how malign foreign states seek to silence, harass and coerce."

Rapid Response Mechanism head Larisa Galadza, Global Affairs Canada

Paul Chiang is seeking re-election in Markham-Unionville, a riding he took from the Conservatives in 2021 by a margin of fewer than 2,500 votes. Justin Tang The Canadian Press file photo

"If  you can take him to the Chinese Consulate General in Toronto, you can get the million-dollar reward", advised Liberal electoral candidate Paul Chiang to an news conference comprised of Chinese-language media, in reference to Conservative candidate Joe Tay who had been charged under the Hong Kong national security law as a threat to Beijing for his Canada-based YouTube channel critical of the Beijing-dominated CCP government.

 

When the comment hit headlines in the legacy media in Canada, calls for the Liberal party to disown Mr. Chiang and remove him as a Liberal candidate for the April 28 federal election expressed the disgust of most Canadians. Derisory statements by opposing political party candidates are not uncommon during election campaigns, but seldom do they cross the line into currying to foreign interference in Canada's affairs and certainly never to the extent that one candidate incites to violence against another.

 

Pressure came fast and furious even within the Liberal party for Mr. Chaing to be removed as a candidate in view of his comments last week. The bounty in  question, in Hong Kong dollars $1 million, transcribes to $183,000 in Canadian currency. Any taker could be assured of earning themselves a reward for luring the Conservative candidate to appear at the Chinese Consulate General in Toronto where he would be spirited to China and imprisoned as a traitor to Beijing -- but certainly not to China.

 

Mr. Chaing informed the Chinese-language media that given Mr. Tay's position on China and Beijing's response, should Mr. Tay be elected to Parliament, the Hong King criminal charge would be a cause of "great controversy", according to the Ming Pao newspaper. And no doubt it would, since the Liberal Party goes out of its way to pacify Beijing, and continues to build on its relationship through trade, despite the assaults on Canadian sovereignty where Canadians have been falsely imprisoned, Canadians have received the death penalty in China, and Chinese interference in Canadian affairs is deeply troubling.

 

Liberal Leader Mark Carney says Paul Chiang will remain a candidate under his banner, despite calls to drop the Markham-Unionville incumbent for suggesting people turn in a Conservative candidate to the Chinese consulate and collect a bounty.   CBC News

Even so, even when Canadian Intelligence has warned government on many occasions through updated reports that China is among those countries -- foremost among those countries -- that have used their expatriate Chinese-Canadian community originally from Mainland China to act as agents for Beijing, as well as instructing all expats that it is their ancestral patriotic duty to infiltrate and capture whatever advances in technology, science, medicine, and military news helpful to be conveyed to China's possession.

 

Mr. Chiang himself saw fit to apologize soon after  his comments were publicized:

"The comments I made were deplorable and a complete lapse of judgement on the seriousness of the matter. I sincerely apologize and deeply regret my comments."

"I will always continue to stand shoulder to shoulder with the people of Hong Kong in their fight to safeguard their human rights and freedoms."

 

And while unelected PM-incumbent Mark Carney is satisfied to let the matter lie there and continue to approve Mr. Chiang as a Liberal candidate, the man himself took the initiative to resign from the Liberal candidacy. Whether his apology is sincere is debatable. He still took the right course in apologizing and taking himself out of the election. There is no debate that Mr. Carney, on the other hand, has often engaged in dishonourable conduct. He has bent the truth to suit his fabricated explanations.

 

And on this occasion he has spectacularly failed to act with conscience and integrity. Canadians should hold him to account for this, yet another lapse in judgement on his part. On the other hand, government officials tasked with identifying and responding to foreign threats during the election period acknowledge they are monitoring the situation closely. Moreover, the RCMP has opened an investigation in the matter. While the man aspiring to be elected Prime Minister of Canada succumbed to his own lack of moral integrity.

 

Mr. Tay has been left uneasy and concerned over his safety, given the obvious nature of the threats against him posed by a foreign government whose record on human rights is abysmal. He has stated that the situation left him fearing for his safety. Spurring him to get in touch with the RCMP for his personal protection, and demanding that Carney fire Chiang. A demand that thirteen pro-democracy groups in Canada linked to Hong Kong produced a statement urging the Liberal Party to "send a clear message" in removing Chiang's candidacy, making it clear they cannot accept his "insincere apology".  

"I want to be clear: no apology is sufficient."

"Threats like these are the tradecraft of the Chinese Communist Party to interfere in Canada."

"And they are not just aimed at me. They are intended to send a chilling signal to the entire community in order to force compliance to Beijing's political goals."

Conservative federal election candidate Joe Tay 

"[Foreign interference, including instances of transnational repression, continue to be a] pervasive threat in Canada [and the federal police takes all reports and allegations seriously]."

"The RCMP is looking into the matter, however no specific details can be provided at this time."

"To ensure the integrity of our investigations, the RCMP typically does not disclose information relating to investigations unless criminal charges are laid, rendering it a matter of public record."

RCMP spokesperson Kristine Kelly 

Conservative Leader Pierre Poilievre, speaking in New Brunswick, says Liberal Leader Mark Carney’s decision to stand by candidate Paul Chiang, who called for people to turn in Conservative candidate Joe Tay for a Chinese bounty, ‘teaches us that Mark Carney will never stand up for Canada.’ Poilievre added that he spoke to Tay and he is ‘very, very rattled.’   CBC

"It is a teachable moment. It teaches us that Mark Carney will never stand up for Canada."

"The Chinese government literally wants to kill Joe Tay because he’s a political dissident. And this candidate said that that should happen."

"I have never in my life seen a prime minister unwilling to protect a Canadian citizen against a foreign government that wants to take his life through a bounty."

Conservative Leader Pierre Poilievre